Photo: Flickr.com / Duncan Rawlinson CC BY-NC-ND

A smorgasbord of sustainable solutions

Environmentally aware public procurement and the inclusion of sustainability in dietary guidelines are some measures already taken in the transition towards a sustainable food system.

“The Solutions Menu”1 is a report from the Nordic Council of Ministers featuring 24 practical examples of measures within the food sector in the Nordic countries. Around half of them are directly or indirectly relevant for environmental sustainability. Here follows some of the most interesting.

A holistic approach

Unlike many other similar documents, the “Climate Programme for Finnish Agriculture – Steps towards Climate Friendly Food”2, published in 2014, includes measures on both the production side and consumption side. This dual approach increases the likelihood that unwanted effects such as “carbon leakage” due to food imports and exports are detected and dealt with. One of the areas of action is reducing meat consumption, since “lower meat consumption is the main means for reducing greenhouse gas emissions from food consumption”. The suggested measures include developing domestic plant-based proteins and more advice for public kitchens.

Climate-smart food models

S.M.A.R.T. is an abbreviation for a checklist used by public kitchens in Sweden since 20013, in order to reduce environmental impact and improve health. The model entails: a larger proportion of vegetable-based food; fewer empty calories; a higher proportion of organic food; the right choice of meat and vegetables; and cutting down on transport.

The Danish Food and Veterinary Agency gives practical advice to consumers on how to eat more climate friendly.4 The recommendations include: finding climate-friendly alternatives to favourite foods (especially alternatives to meat); using more seasonal vegetables in all meals; consuming fish from Denmark; planning trips to the supermarket so as not to waste fuel on unnecessary trips; and avoiding the waste of food by eating leftovers.

Dietary guidelines

Back in 2012 the Nordic Nutrition Recommendations5 included a chapter about sustainable food consumption. One conclusion was that eating according to the recommendations has a lower environmental impact than the average Nordic diet.

Two years later, in 2014, the Finnish Nutrient Recommendations6 advocate higher intakes of vegetables, berries, fruit, whole-grain cereal products and fish, and lower intakes of red meat and meat products in general. If people were to follow these recommendations the environmental impact from food could be reduced by 20 per cent according to the document.

When the Swedish dietary guidelines7 were updated in 2015 they included wordings that acknowledge that plant-based foods have less of an environmental impact than foods of animal origin. Decreasing the consumption of foods of animal origin and increasing the consumption of plant-based foods is recommended to reduce the climate impact of the modern Swedish diet.

Finally, the Norwegian National Action Plan for a Healthier Diet8, published in 2017, suggests that a diet consisting of more fruit and vegetables, more fish and less meat, is a more sustainable diet.

Local government procurement

In 2006, the City of Copenhagen raised their goal for organic ingredients in meals cooked in public kitchens from 45 per cent to 90 per cent by 2015. This should be done without any additional funding, which required kitchens to rethink menus, work flows, food waste and procurement. The aim was also to improve the quality of food.

Since then other Nordic cities have set similarly ambitious targets:

  • Malmö, Sweden (population: 341,000): 100% organic by 2020, goal set in 2010
  • Helsinki, Finland (population: 630,000): 50% organic in preschools and day-care centres by 2015, goal set in 2011
  • Gothenburg, Sweden (population: 572,000): 100% organic meat, goal set in 2014
  • Lund, Sweden (population: 119,000): 100% organic food by 2020, goal set in 2015
  • Oslo, Norway (population: 672,000): 50% organic food by 2020, goal set in 2016
  • Lejre, Denmark (population: 27,000): 75% organic food by 2021, goal set in 2017

Besides these local initiatives the report also highlights different national strategies with targets to increase the production and consumption of organic food, such as the “Finland more organic plan” from 2013 and the “Organic Action Plan for Denmark” from 2015.

National food waste strategies

Three of the measures deal with food waste. This includes collecting data to better understand the dynamics of food waste, stakeholder involvement and support for innovative projects. One very hands-on action point has been to review the “best-before” labels on food. It was found that there were huge variations in the estimated durability within different product groups. Many companies have now taken upon themselves to make changes. One of Norway’s largest dairies has added “but-not-bad-after” dates to encourage consumers to use their own discretion to determine if a food item is edible or not.

A sustainable food culture

The link between gastronomy and sustainability is not obvious. In 2004 the Danish TV chef Claus Meyer and scientist Jan Krag Jacobsen drafted the New Nordic Food Manifesto9 as a starting point for a new movement. The ten-point manifesto acknowledges that ethical production should be a core value for the Nordic Kitchen, beside more culinary aspects such as food quality and taste, and this includes using local ingredients in season.

The report describes a trickle-down effect: when fine-dining restaurants started to embrace kale and turnips this inspired lunch restaurants, school canteens and families to follow this new style of cooking.

Kajsa Pira

Further reading:
1 http://norden.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:1214792/FULLTEXT01.pdf
https://mmm.fi/documents/1410837/1890227/Climate_programme_agriculture_W... (in English)
3 https://www.folkhalsomyndigheten.se/contentassets/aa6146887ffb468b8d1efa... (in Swedish)
4 https://altomkost.dk/nyheder/nyhed/nyhed/sund-og-klimarigtig-mad-paa-men... (in Danish)
5 http://www.norden.org/en/theme/former-themes/themes-2016/nordic-nutritio... (in English)
6 https://www.evira.fi/en/foodstuff/healthy-diet/nutrition-recommendations... (in English)
7 https://www.livsmedelsverket.se/globalassets/publikationsdatabas/andra-s... (in English)
8 regjeringen.no/contentassets/fab53cd681b247bfa8c03a3767c75e66/norwegian_national_action_plan_for_a_healthier_diet_an_outline.pdf (in English)
9 http://www.norden.org/en/theme/ny-nordisk-mad/the-new-nordic-food-manifesto

 

Illustration: © Lars-Erik Håkansson

Member states to set the bottom floor

The climate and environment are central objectives in the new CAP proposal, but more flexibility for member states risks undermining delivery on the ground.

Photo: National Renewable Energy Lab CC BY-NC-ND

Editorial: Just doing a little bit is not enough

“Limiting global warming to 1.5°C would require rapid, far-reaching and unprecedented changes in all aspects of society.” This is the main message of the IPCC report released on 8 October. They also conclude “that we ...

Six countries taken to court over air quality breaches

If EU countries do not urgently address their air pollution problems, the European Court of Justice can impose fines amounting to millions of euro.

Hungary is one of six countries referred to the European Court of Justice because their governments have not done enough to improve air quality. Photo: Flickr.com / Tea Meister CC BY
A full implementation of the NEC directive requirements would reduce premature deaths bt 200,000 annually by 2030. Photo: Flickr.com / Eduardo A. Ponce CC BY-NC-ND

EU “Clean Air Outlook” up to 2030

The annual benefits of additional measures needed to achieve the 2030 national emissions ceilings are estimated at €13–58 billion, up to 84 times higher than the estimated costs.

Photo: Flickr.com / Andrew CC BY

Coal will be squeezed out by renewables

Prices of green electricity and batteries have fallen so sharply that projections for 85–90% renewables by 2035 look “ludicrously conservative”, according to the energy coalition ETC.

Lessons from aviation’s first foray into market-based measures

International Civil Aviation Organization landed on the cheapest, most contentious, and finally outdated policy instrument out there – offsetting.

Photo: © Shutterstock – Arseniy Shemyakin Photo
Illustrations: © Shutterstock – PytY and © Shutterstock – Alzbeta

Europe still building new coal power stations

Several countries in Europe have recently built or are planning to build new coal power stations. Some examples from Germany were described in the last issue of Acid News (AN2/2018), and further examples of such plants from Eastern Europe are presented here.

Photo: Flickr.com / Junep A CC BY

Germany must exit coal quickly

A study conducted by the Fraunhofer Institute for Energy Economics and Energy System Technology posits that Germany can still meet its 2020 emissions reduction target.

Swedes harmed by air pollution

Every year 7600 people in Sweden die prematurely due to nitrogen dioxide and particulate matter, with an annual cost to society of at least 5.3 billion euro.

Photo: Flickr.com / Stefan Leijon CC BY-ND
Photo: Ammonia emissions increased in fifteen member states. Photo: Flickr.com / Andrew CC BY

Agricultural ammonia emissions keep on rising

Five EU countries breached their national emission ceilings for ammonia in 2016 and total emissions have now increased by two per cent over three years, preliminary data from the European Environment Agency (EEA) shows.

Patterns: © Shutterstock – Graham Corney, © Shutterstock – eNjoy iStyle, © Shutterstock – jeagun lee

Three easy apples to pick

Some types of change require long-term planning, new institutions, educating a new generation etc. Other things are so easy to do that they should have been implemented yesterday.

Wind farms and birds

Wind farms are far less harmful to birds than first thought, according to the biggest ever study on the subject published in April, because seabirds actively change their flight paths to avoid them.

Photo: Flickr.com /Steve P2008 CC BY
Photo: Flickr.com / Duncan Rawlinson CC BY-NC-ND

A smorgasbord of sustainable solutions

Environmentally aware public procurement and the inclusion of sustainability in dietary guidelines are some measures already taken in the transition towards a sustainable food system.

Värtaverket in Stockholm, the last coal-fired heating plant in Sweden. Photo: Flickr.com / Arvid Rudling CC BY-SA

Sweden to stop using coal for energy in 2022

The burning of coal for heat and power in Sweden will stop in 2022, which is the deadline for the combined heat and power plant in Stockholm.

Solar radiation management (SRM) and geoengineering are not needed

SRM is perilous, as the consequnces of intervening in a highly complex system are unpredictable. Actual GHG emissions cuts can achieve more, faster, surer, cheaper and without the risk.

Photo: Flickr.com/Bruno Caimi CC BY
Photo: © Shutterstock – durantelallera

Cruise ship ranking

In its updated cruise ship ranking, German environmentalist organisation NABU (Nature And Biodiversity Conservation Union) concludes that just one newly built cruise ship, the AIDAnova, renounces the use ...

One of the electrified harbour buses that soon will be in traffic in the Danish capital. Photo: Damen.com

Five fully-electric ferries in Copenhagen

The multinational public transport company Arriva Danmark has recently contracted Damen Shipyards Group for five fully-electric ferries, to be operated for the Danish public transport agency MOVIA, in Copenhagen ...

Photo: Flickr.com / Thor CC BY

LNG wrong course

Switching to liquefied natural gas (LNG) is a costly and ineffective way of reducing greenhouse gas emissions from shipping, according to a new study commissioned by Transport & Environment. While LNG ...

Photo: Flickr.com / Tom CC BY-ND

Norway heading for zero-emission ships

Norway has set its sights on creating the world’s first zero emissions control area (ZECA). A resolution adopted by the Norwegian Parliament on 3 May seeks to halt emissions from cruise ships and ferries in the Norwegian ...

Hiding? No I am just adjusting this wall. Photo: © Shutterstock – Arman Novic

Member states ask EU to help hide their air pollution failure

Eleven governments have asked the European Commission to retrospectively raise their “emission ceilings” after breaching their national air pollution limits in 2016, namely: Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland ...

Court ruling demands ban on older diesel cars by February. Photo: Flickr.com / Volker Kannacher CC BY-ND-SA

Frankfurt must ban older diesel cars

Frankfurt must ban highly-polluting, older diesel vehicles from the city centre from February 2019 as part of a plan to improve air quality, the Administrative Court in Wiesbaden ruled on 5 September. ClientEarth lawyer ...

Photo: © Shutterstock – Kiszon Pascal

Diesel cars cause high health costs

Recent research by scientists at the University of Oxford and University of Bath suggests that the health damage effects associated with diesel vehicle emissions are around 20 times greater than electric vehicles ...

Photo: © Shutterstock – aydngvn

Support for renewables over coal in Turkish poll

While Turkey’s President Recep Erdogan has strongly promoted new coal power plants, only 5.2 per cent of 2595 residents surveyed preferred coal power, compared to 70 per cent support for solar and 52.8 per cent support ...

Photo: Flickr.com / Collierwilson CC BY-NC-ND

EU livestock numbers are too high

“What is the Safe Operating Space for EU livestock?” is the question at issue and the title of a new report from the Rise Foundation. Their preliminary analysis shows that the numbers of farm animals in Europe ...

You know the feeling when small countries end up being underwater and they tell you to rewrite your national climate plan. Photo: © Shutterstock – Kjetil Kolbjornsrud

Climate-vulnerable countries: 2015 commitments are outdated

The Climate Vulnerable Forum (CVF) has urged countries to step up and revise their national climate plans without further delay. “Growing climate risks, economic and technological developments in low-carbon technology" ...

Report suggests sales restrictions. Photo: © Shutterstock – Casey Bollig

No more sales of wet firewood in the UK

Retailers could face restrictions on selling wet wood as a fuel for household heating, under plans announced by the UK government on 17 August to tackle particulate (PM) air pollution, following on from the launch of the government’s Clean Air Strategy this summer.

Photo: © Shutterstock – bhathaway

Zero-emission construction machinery

Construction sites are the source of various forms of pollution, such as material waste, visible dust, noise, and vibration. But they also produce air pollution, especially nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM).

In brief

London ULEZ to expand from October 2021

London’s Ultra Low Emission Zone will expand out to the North and South Circular roads from 25 October 2021 and cover an area 18 times larger than the Central London ULEZ, the Mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, confirmed on 8 June.

The ULEZ is to be introduced in the centre of the city from early 2019, before expanding out to the North and South Circulars in 2021 – and will increase the emissions standards for vehicles operating in the capital. Replacing the current T-Charge, the ULEZ would see vehicles that do not meet emission standards liable to incur a daily charge to drive within the zone, ranging from £12.50 for some light vehicles, up to an additional £100 for some heavy goods vehicles which do not meet the Euro VI emissions limit.

Source: AirQualityNews, 8 June 2018.

Denmark to ban new fossil fuel cars by 2035

The Danish government has launched a climate and air pollution package called “together for a cleaner world”, which includes 38 initiatives. The country aims to ban sales of petrol and diesel cars by 2030 and sales of plug-in hybrids by 2035. This should be enough to achieve a fossil-free car fleet by 2050. This would reduce annual CO2 emissions by 7 million tonnes. They also intend to set up a scrapping premium for diesel cars.

Besides transport measures, the package also includes initiatives to promote precision farming with the ambition to reduce ammonia emissions, and improved monitoring of sulphur emissions from the shipping sector.

Source: ENDS Daily 9 October 2018

Sweden will fine high-sulphur ships

After years of preparatory work, the Swedish government has now finally introduced economic sanctions on ships using illegal high-sulphur fuel. The minimum penalty fee is SEK 5,000 (€482) and the maximum SEK 500,000 (€48,200). The higher the engine power and the fuel sulphur content, the higher the penalty. If a company continues to violate the rules the fee can be doubled, potentially reaching SEK 1 million.

As from 1 January 2015, EU legislation as well as rules set by the International Maritime Organization (IMO) require ships to use fuels with a sulphur content not exceeding 0.1 per cent when entering the North Sea and Baltic Sea, which are designated as sulphur emission control areas. In comparison, the sulphur standard for most of the rest of world is currently 3.5 per cent, but will come down to 0.5 per cent as from 2020.

Source: Press release from the Swedish Ministry of Environment, 1 June 2018

Copenhagen mayor wants to ban wood-burning stoves

Copenhagen Mayor Frank Jensen wants to reduce air pollution by banning new wood-burning stoves and offering householders a cash incentive to scrap their old stoves and switch to district heating. Jensen would like to see the cash incentive funded by the state, but if it is unwilling to do so, Copenhagen Municipality is seeking permission to set up a local scrappage scheme.

“In a city where we’ve got district heating in every house there’s no need for wood-burning stoves as a heat source. They are only for ‘hygge’ (cosiness) and that kind of ‘hygge’ is something we will have to wean ourselves off,” he said.

There are more than 16,000 wood-burning stoves in Copenhagen and Frederiksberg, and one study has estimated that 77 premature deaths in 2014 could be directly attributed to particle emissions from wood-burning stoves.

Source: chppost.dk, 30 August 2018
http://cphpost.dk/news/nature-news-in-brief-mayor-wants-to-rid-copenhage...