E-fuels are a detour on our way to decarbonisation

It takes four times as much energy to drive a car on e-fuels compared to batteries. In addition, they emit as much air pollution as a car running on fossil fuels.

At the eleventh hour of the agreed EU-wide phase-out of Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) cars by 2035, Germany wanted to add a loophole. The push was championed by the oil and auto industries, to allow the continued production after 2035 of ICE cars. The push allowed for ICE cars beyond 2035 if they run on synthetic petrol and diesel – also known as e-fuels. This article will reflect on some of the implications of this push.

E-fuels are made by separating hydrogen from water and adding CO₂. Although the fuels themselves may be made using renewable power, the process is energy intensive. The production of e-fuels would likely be a waste of valuable green energy and their combustion would require direct air capture technology to avoid releasing as much greenhouse gas as fossil fuels. It has been calculated that the e-fuels proposal would derail the decarbonisation of the new fleet and displace up to 46 million electric car sales. The e-fuel intended for new cars could instead have played a role in existing combustion engines not having to rely on fossil petrol. It is estimated that the new e-fuel cars could push old ICE cars to an additional burning of 135 billion litres of fossil petrol.

Furthermore, the complex production processes for e-fuels will make them expensive and energy-dense. In 2030, an average driver in the EU would pay €782 a year more for e-petrol than for conventional fuel, according to Transport & Environment studies. The Potsdam Institute has also calculated that the industrial-scale use of direct air capture to produce e-fuels would mean they would cost four times the price of petrol. Pulling molecules out of air and water is energy-intensive, making it four times more efficient to use renewable electricity to charge an electric vehicle battery than to use it to make e-fuel for a car, according to an International Council on Clean Transport (ICCT) study. If all planned e-fuel projects were to materialise, the Potsdam institute forecasts that, by 2035, global production would still cover only 10 per cent of Germany’s essential demand for e-fuels (from aviation, shipping, and the chemical industry).

And finally, the German push was also a sad day for air pollution, as combustion inevitably emits pollutants. While synthetic fuels can at least theoretically be carbon neutral, they still emit air pollutants, notably toxic NO₂ and carcinogenic particles. Cars running on e-fuels could emit up to 160,000 tonnes of additional NOx pollution in the EU by 2050 – more toxic emissions than from Italy’s car fleet in an entire year. A study comparing air pollution from e-fuels with petrol found no reduction in NOx emissions for any of the e-fuels tested, either in the lab or on road tests, compared to today’s petrol fuel, so the use of e-fuels in cars will have little impact on toxic NO₂/NOx pollution across Europe’s cities. While there was a decrease in particle number concentrations for e-fuels, they still emit an enormous number of particles – at least 2.2 billion particles for every kilometre driven. There was no difference in particle mass concentrations and there was an increase in carbon monoxide, ammonia and hydrocarbon emissions from e-fuels compared to fossil fuels. So, the push for e-fuels is not a push for cleaner air.
With road traffic being a large contributor to the air pollution problem in our cities, maybe e-fuels are best used in other areas. One person who is a bit more positive about e-fuels is Roland Dittmeyer, director of the Institute for Micro Process Engineering at the Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT) in Germany. Dittmeyer drives an electric vehicle but thinks e-fuel might be a helpful alternative for de-carbonising aviation where heavy batteries might be a hindrance for longer distances.

One might ask who, given all the above, would push for e-fuels in passenger cars?

Seven of the eFuel Alliance’s 15 board members currently work, or have previously worked, in the oil industry, including Jens-Christian Senger, ExxonMobil’s managing director in Germany. Even if the push for a fossil-free society is underway, the question is now one of speed and scale. The oil industry’s game is to slow things down in Europe while building up fossil demand elsewhere. But as the IPCC laid out very clearly, the future of our planet and our children requires us to move out of oil, coal and gas at breakneck speed.

Ebba Malmqvist

T&E 31 March 2023, "The big e-fuel lie https://www.transportenvironment.org/discover/the-big-e-fuel-lie/
PIK March 2023, E-Fuels - Aktueller Stand und Projektionen, https://www.pik-potsdam.de/members/Ueckerdt/E-Fuels_Stand-und-Projektion...

Fuels

In this issue

Making the most of waste heat

The total excess heat in the EU covers almost all of the EU’s total energy demand for heat and hot water in residential and service sector buildings. This potential needs to be utilised, especially during these times of energy and climate crises.

Editorial: EU could be powered by recycled heat

Preventing heat waste has largely been ignored as a solution. A new report by the global engineering company Danfoss highlights the potential of excess heat recovery.

Germany shuts down last three nuclear reactors, ending nuclear power era

Germany switched off its last three nuclear reactors on 15 April, marking the end of its nuclear power era.

Global heating threatens northern forests

In the last month, fires have ravaged forests in both Canada and Russia. This is just the latest of many similar examples.

Unlocking the potential of ocean energy

To ensure affordable energy and limit global temperature rise to below 1.5 °C there is an urgent need to transition rapidly from a centralised energy system that heavily relies on fossil fuels. Ocean energy is one of the technologies that should be scaled up to support the transition of the energy system to reach full decarbonisation.

A quantative take on Russian forests

Russia has one fifth of the global forest area. This area has remained relatively constant in recent decades, but clear cutting and wildfires are altering the species composition.

Ocean acidification in the climate negotiations

If ocean acidification was redefined as an effect of climate change, the UNFCCC could interpret its existing framework so that parties were required to take action on the issue.

The forefront of cleaner, people-centred cities

Cities are dense and struggling with high levels of air pollution, sedentary behaviour and noise problems linked to car-centred urban planning. Traffic also takes up large areas in cities, resulting in lack of green spaces, and it is obvious that our oil dependency has fuelled climate change. Three cities with governments that are up for the challenge of re-thinking cities are Paris, Oslo and Barcelona, which are working to transform their cities from car-
centred to people-centred.

The Swedish Greenwashing Prize – more than a decade of ironic awards highlighting misleading claims

Each year, for over a decade, Friends of the Earth Sweden has announced a winner of its Swedish Greenwashing Prize – an ironic booby prize that turns the spotlight on misleading and false claims.

The EU needs to do more to reduce methane emissions

The EU has signed the Global Methane Pledge but action to slash methane emissions in the energy and agriculture sectors is lagging behind. Urgent measures are needed to reduce methane emissions while at the same time much more action is also needed to reduce all other greenhouse gas emissions.

E-fuels are a detour on our way to decarbonisation

It takes four times as much energy to drive a car on e-fuels compared to batteries. In addition, they emit as much air pollution as a car running on fossil fuels.

Green incentives are at the heart as UK rolls out its CAP replacement

Public money for public goods is the principle behind the new Environmental Land Management schemes in England – the jury is still out on whether it can sustain farmers’ livelihoods while also protecting the environment.

Nitrogen deposition threat to 60 per cent of European ecosystems

Most affected are regions with intensive livestock rearing. Scenarios show that both technical measures and a reduction in animal numbers are needed to tackle the problem.

Dramatic vanishing of polar sea ice and ice sheets

Polar sea ice and ice sheets are continuing to melt rapidly according to many new studies. The end-of-winter Arctic sea ice extent in March 2023 was the fifth lowest in the satellite record, while the area of Antarctic sea ice fell to a record low.

Main menu

E-fuels are a detour on our way to decarbonisation

In this issue

Making the most of waste heat

Editorial: EU could be powered by recycled heat

Germany shuts down last three nuclear reactors, ending nuclear power era

Global heating threatens northern forests

Unlocking the potential of ocean energy

A quantative take on Russian forests

Ocean acidification in the climate negotiations

The forefront of cleaner, people-centred cities

The Swedish Greenwashing Prize – more than a decade of ironic awards highlighting misleading claims

The EU needs to do more to reduce methane emissions

E-fuels are a detour on our way to decarbonisation

Green incentives are at the heart as UK rolls out its CAP replacement

Nitrogen deposition threat to 60 per cent of European ecosystems

Dramatic vanishing of polar sea ice and ice sheets

Publications

Food for Thought

Northern forests, climate change and the UNFCCC

EU climate targets aligned with the Paris agreement’s 1.5°C objective

Baltic Sea Offshore Wind Collaborative-Learning project

Air pollution in Europe and children’s health

Climate Change: A Himalayan Odessey

No further discussion needed. The agreed global goal is to limit temperature rise to 1.5°C

Fossil-free electricity 2021

What we do

Air pollution

Climate Change

Policy initiatives

Do Your Bit!