Weak EU coal pollution standards carry high costs

Draft new EU emission limits for coal-fired power stations are so weak that they could result in health damage, including the loss of over 23 million working days, which would cost over €52 billion between 2020 and 2029.

A new study by environmental economist Mike Holland, commissioned by environmental groups European Environmental Bureau (EEB) and Greenpeace, shows that the EU’s draft new power plant pollution regulation could lead to 71,000 avoidable deaths in the decade after 2020 because the currently proposed standards do not require application of the readily available, most effective emission abatement techniques.

Coal-fired power plants are the largest source of sulphur dioxide (SO₂) and mercury emissions in Europe and one of the largest industrial sources of emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx), arsenic, lead and cadmium. Emissions of SO₂, NOx, and dust particles from coal plant smokestacks are key contributors to increased concentrations of particulate matter (PM2.5), a pollutant that has been found to increase the risk of stroke, heart disease and lung cancer.

The EU is currently in the process of updating its emission standards for large combustion plants, including lignite- and coal-fired power plants. The standards are published in “best available techniques reference documents” (BREF) (see Box) and are – as indicated by the name – meant to be based on the best available techniques (BAT), but the current EU proposal is far weaker than standards at existing coal plants in China, Japan and the United States (see AN 2/15, p. 16–17).

The new EU standards would apply from 2020–2029 and set emission limit values for toxic air emissions, including sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, mercury, and dust particles – pollutants that all have significant documented effects on health and the environment.
“EU decision-makers should not bring ‘state-of-the-art’ environmental standards down to the levels of industry laggards or base them on least-cost options,” said Christian Schaible, EEB policy manager on industrial pollution.

Official EU data has been used in the study to model the health impacts of the proposed new EU emission standards, comparing them to the impacts of standards based on BAT. The numbers for deaths, illnesses and costs express the difference between application of the two standards.
It is estimated that the health damage from the excess pollution that could result from the weak standards would cost over €52 billion over 20202029 (see table). It should be noted that this figure is based on the most conservative estimate of the health benefits, and that it would increase by roughly a factor three if the upper bound for economic impacts were used instead.

Greenpeace EU energy policy adviser Tara Connolly said: “The human, environmental and economic cost of a sell-out to the coal industry is huge. Children will pay the heaviest price, with hundreds of thousands of avoidable cases of asthma, lung cancer and heart conditions. There is no justification for politicians who refuse to apply existing technology that can bring down deadly coal pollution. Coal causes irreparable damage and it’s high time for the EU to set a pathway to start phasing it out.”

Christer Ågren
The report: “Health and economic implications of alternative emission limits for coal-fired power plants in the EU” (May 2015).
 

Health impact Unit  Difference
Mortality (30+ yr Deaths 71,200
Acute bronchitis (27+ yr) Cases 204,500
Chronic Bronchitis (27+ yr) Cases 60,600
Respiratory hospital admission (all ages) Admissions 29,000
Cardiac hospital admissions (18+ yr) Admissions 28,800
Asthma symptom days (children 5-19 yr) Days 2,160,200
Restricted activity days (all ages) Days 83,484,800
Lost working days (15-64 yr) Days 23,222,700
IQ loss from mercury IQ points 29,600
Overall costs billion € 52.45

 

1.5°C target adequate for Paris agreement

The 2°C goal for global warming is inadequate. Risks increase significantly between 1.5 and 2°C, a UN review of climate targets concludes.

Editorial: The road from Paris

At the UN climate conference in December 2015 in Paris, 196 countries will hopefully adopt a new global agreement for strong greenhouse gas reductions.

Environment MEPs want stricter air pollutant caps

Member states should meet stricter 2025 and 2030 air pollution reduction targets and mercury should also be included in the National Emission Ceilings directive, says the Parliament’s Environment Committee.
 

A future based on 100 % renewable energy for all is achievable

Greenpeace has launched the new edition of the popular Energy [R]evolution report “How to Achieve 100% Renewable Energy for All by 2050”.
 

Film:1.5 Stay Alive

AirClim has co-published a 50-minute documentary and Caribbean music film about climate change in the coastal zones of the Caribbean Region.

Exposing the role of coal in Europe – launch of European Coal Map

There is now a comprehensive overview of existing and planned coal power plants that also displays key information on pollution and health impact, presented by the Climate Action Network (CAN).

Deal on pollution from medium combustion plants

While EU-wide application of readily available emission abatement techniques would reduce NOx emissions from these plants by more than 80 per cent by 2025, the new directive will deliver less than half of this reduction.

Weak EU coal pollution standards carry high costs

Draft new EU emission limits for coal-fired power stations are so weak that they could result in health damage, including the loss of over 23 million working days, which would cost over €52 billion between 2020 and 2029.

140 000 life-years lost each year in London because of air pollution

Inclusion of the impact of nitrogen dioxide for the first time suggests that more than twice as many people as previously thought die prematurely from air pollution in London.

Lower speed – less emissions?

Ships in the Mediterranean Sea have reduced their speed by more than 30 per cent since 2008, which has led to a 45 per cent cut in average ship NOx emission factors.

Emissions keep on slowly shrinking

Air pollutant emissions from land-based sources are continuing to fall slightly, but considerably slower than before. Some of the reductions on land are also countered by rising emissions from international shipping.

Pledges for the 2015 UN climate agreement

South Korea plans to cut emissions by 37 percent by 2030, and China plans to boost renewables. As the Paris conference approaches, countries are submitting their plans for greenhouse gas reductions.

Dirty diesel cars tested

Emissions tests on 32 Euro 6 diesel passenger cars from ten different manufacturers and with different abatement technologies show that most cars fail to meet the NOx emissions standards under more realistic driving conditions.

Lignite villages have been needlessly destroyed

Lignite has a low energy output and requires huge quantities to be mined, which has a devastating impact on landscapes and settlements. Even so, many countries are still committed to the fuel.

EU air pollution emissions still exceeded

Ten EU countries breached at least one of their air pollutant emission ceilings in 2013, preliminary data from the European Environment Agency (EEA) shows.