Restoring wetlands benefits both biodiversity and carbon storage. Photo: © Basotxerri / Shutterstock.com

Revising LULUCF regulation could be a chance for both climate and biodiversity

The European Union carbon sink must more than double by 2030. The cheapest way to do this is by protecting and restoring forests, peatlands, and other natural ecosystems.

While drastic emission reductions are key to averting catastrophic climate change, diverse and resilient lands and forests have long been recognised as equally important. The ways we use our land and forests require urgent changes which should be in line with the speed and scale of the climate emergency we are facing.

Following an agreement on a revised EU 2030 target of at least 55% net greenhouse gas emission reductions, in July the European Commission presented proposals to revise the EU climate and energy legislation for the period 2021–2030, including the EU Regulation on Land Use, Land Use Change and Forestry, known as LULUCF, which aims to tackle the carbon flows in forests and on land in the EU.

In recent years the EU carbon sink provided by the LULUCF sectors has decreased significantly to a value of 265 Mt of CO2 in 2019. This last figure consists of around 135 Mt of emissions (mainly from croplands, wetlands and land conversion to settlements) and 400 Mt of removals (mainly from managed forests). Under the current policy the sink is allowed to further decrease to 225 Mt by 2030 without member states accumulating any debits. This is what is expected if member states move on with their plans to increase forest harvesting and continue to drain peatland soils for agriculture, forestry and peat extraction.

To meet the long-term goals of the Paris Agreement, the LULUCF sectors need to urgently increase the amount of CO2 that is removed from the atmosphere and stored in landscapes. This must be done while restoring ecosystems in order to support and enhance the long-term viability of natural resources, ecosystem services, biodiversity and ecological food production. If the EU wants to contribute towards limiting warming to 1.5°C without significant overshoot, there is a pressing need for the land sector to be part of the solution over this current decade.

European NGOs call on the EU to aim to increase the LULUCF sector’s net carbon sink to 600 Mt of CO2 annually by 2030. This is based on a number of academic studies assessing the potential size of an ecologically viable LULUCF sink in the EU, aligned with adaptation needs and the EU’s Biodiversity Strategy. Öko Institute’s exploratory analysis, which reviews a wide range of studies, assesses a potential for an EU net sink of up to 600 Mt annually by 2030. The EU Transition Pathways Explorer EUCalc, put together by a large academic consortium, shows potential for a LULUCF sink of 570 Mt per year in 2030, and 787 Mt in 2050.

To achieve a net LULUCF carbon sink of 600 Mt by 2030 there need to be radical changes in the way we use land across the EU. Most importantly, forest harvesting rates must be reduced significantly and forests must be managed with a close-to-nature approach, as the forests’ ability to absorb carbon is closely related to harvesting rates. There needs to be a significant reduction in the consumption and production of animal products, such as meat and dairy, a reform of the EU’s bioenergy rules, and a shift to a more circular economy. Emissions from organic soils need to be drastically reduced, through careful application of re-wetting approaches, and carbon stocks on cropland need to be dramatically increased, through a major expansion of agroforestry and other climate and biodiversity-friendly farming practices.

Net removals by the LULUCF sector need to be additional to emission reductions in other sectors and kept under a separate target with no flexibility with the Emissions Trading System (ETS) and Effort Sharing Regulation (ESR) sectors. This is critical because emission reductions and removals in the LULUCF sector are not equal to emissions in other sectors and the two cannot simply be considered interconvertible. Measuring emissions and removals in the land sector is less accurate and land-based carbon stocks cannot be considered permanent in the same way as reducing fossil fuel emissions and keeping fossil fuels in the ground can. The climate and ecological crisis requires all sectors to exert their maximum effort, without progress in one undermining progress in the other.

The LULUCF sector is fundamental, not just to climate change mitigation, but also to the EU’s natural environment, its wildlife and people. Changes in the incentives for forestry and land use can have either negative or positive consequences for biodiversity. The revised legislation must remain mindful of the impacts to biodiversity and ensure that concrete links are drawn between the LULUCF Regulation and the EU’s biodiversity objectives, including those set out in the Biodiversity Strategy, in the Restoration Law and the Birds and Habitats Directive.

The revision of the LULUCF Regulation is an important opportunity in the EU’s aim to mitigate both climate and biodiversity crises. For this to happen, more adequate targets as well as better-defined and transparent rules are needed in order for the LULUCF sector to stay in line with the path towards climate neutrality. Protecting and restoring forests, peatlands, and other natural ecosystems remains the cheapest, most effective and only readily available way to accomplish that.

Ulriikka Aarnio

 

Illustration: © Lars-Erik Håkansson

Dependence on fossil gas cause soaring energy bills

As the world recovers from the pandemic, energy prices in the European Union have surged to record-high levels and the only way forward is renewables.

Photo: Paul van de Velde CC BY / Flickr.com

Editorial: Promising ruling against the Energy Charter Treaty

Europe’s top court has ruled that the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) cannot be used in lawsuits between EU countries.

NGOs demand a fully renewable energy system by 2040 in Europe

An initiative of Climate Action Network (CAN) Europe calls for a 100% renewable energy system by 2040 (heat, transport and industry) and 100% renewable electricity by 2035.

The benefits of solar and wind can be enjoyed by everyone with the right policies and measures. Photo: © Maria Galvin/ Shutterstock.com
Energy sufficiency aims at keeping consumption at a sustainable level. Photo: © maxzed / Shutterstock.com

Energy sufficiency: a necessary complement to energy efficiency

Making the case for energy sufficiency in European policies: the construction of a European sufficiency-based energy transition scenario.

Illustration: © Eugenia Petrovskaya / Shutterstock.com

Taxing livestock to reduce nitrogen and GHG emissions

A recent report provides three concrete proposals on how livestock could be taxed to reduce ammonia and greenhouse gas emissions, while generating funds for reforms.

Closing the nitrogen cycle with agroecology

Study shows that it is possible to halve nitrogen losses in Europe by abolishing synthetic fertilisers, reconnecting livestock and cropping systems and changing diets.

Nitrogen-fixing crops, manure and recycled human urine are used as fertilisers in the scenario. Photo: © Photoagriculture / Shutterstock.com
Restoring wetlands benefits both biodiversity and carbon storage. Photo: © Basotxerri / Shutterstock.com

Revising LULUCF regulation could be a chance for both climate and biodiversity

The European Union carbon sink must more than double by 2030. The cheapest way to do this is by protecting and restoring forests, peatlands, and other natural ecosystems.

Photo: © Photocreo Michal Bednarek / Shutterstock.com

A global roadmap to “climate-smart” offshore renewable energy

The Global Wind Energy Council and UN Global Compact launched a roadmap to advance offshore renewable energy on 5 November – “Ocean Day” – at COP 26.

WHO guidelines are based on science – policy should follow

Detailed models and data from more parts of the world are behind the lower acceptable levels for particles, ozone and nitrogen dioxide in the new WHO air quality guidelines.

More advanced models can capture the spatial variation of air pollution levels within cities. Photo: © TonyV3112 / Shutterstock.com
Fossil advertising persuades us to buy more and bigger cars, fly more often over longer distances and use more fossil fuels. Photo: © Jeppe Gustafsson / Shutterstock.Com

Time to ban climate-threating advertising

European NGOs push to prohibit advertising for fossil fuels, fossil-fuelled cars and air travel. Several European cities have taken the lead by introducing local bans.

EIght out of nine member states analysed must redo their homework for a 1.5°C compatible target. Illustration: © iralu / Shutterstock.com

Solutions to reach 1.5°C still available

Study on 1.5 pathways concludes that EU can reduce greenhouse gases by at least 65% by 2030. This means a transition to 100% renewable electricity while reducing energy use.

A different COP – Communities of Practice – encourages offshore cooperation

The development of offshore wind farms has gained momentum in the EU but to accelerate deployment the challenge of conflicting interests within marine areas needs to be addressed. A new study examines the potential of so-called Communities of Practice (COPs).

The Netherlands has taken steps to involve stakeholders in the planning of multi-use offshore wind farms. Photo: © T.W. van Urk / Shutterstock.com
Photo: © lastdjedai / Shutterstock.com

Methane pledge must be followed by a fossil fuel phase-out target

The EU needs to improve its methane pledge. Emissions must be reduced by at least 70% by 2030 compared to 1990, in order to provide a fair contribution to the 1.5°C target.

The vehicle fleet is the greatest contributor to outdoor urban air pollution. Photo: © Sarine Arslanian / Shutterstock.com

Air pollution in Africa

Air pollution in Africa differs from that in developed countries. The main contributors to particle emissions are old vehicles, burning of waste and use of biomass for cooking.

EU institutions ignore latest evidence when evaluating health effects

More recent data of PM2.5 show greater effects on mortality. Although some of this research is more than seven years old, it has not been incoporated in currently used models.

Including results from newer studies in the models would show greater health costs. Photo: © Monika Wisniewska / Shutterstock.com
© Bogdan Vacarciuc / Shutterstock.com

Ocean acidification: the “Black elephant” in the Black Sea?

The acidification problem is, indeed, a “black elephant” – an obvious, predictable event with enormous consequences, but highly overlooked by many stakeholders, which is also relevant for the Black Sea region.

Photo: © M. Volk / Shutterstock.com

30 billion euro to repair after German flooding

The severe flooding which hit Germany in summer 2021, in which more than 170 people died, also resulted in high costs.

Tighter standards for PM2.5 could reduce mortality in the US. Photo: © ehrlif/ Shutterstock.com

US EPA new air quality policy assessment

The US EPA has published a draft policy assessment of the National Ambient Air Quality Standards ...

Coastal areas will see continued sea level rise throughout the 21st century, contributing to more frequent and severe coastal flooding in low-lying areas. Photo: © Sk Hasan Ali / Shutterstock.com

IPCC: Climate change is widespread, rapid, and intensifying

The IPCC has summarised the main conclusions of its WG 1 physical science report from August 2021 in a press release.

Natural ecosystemes all over the world are needed to store carbon.

Places to preserve to avoid climate chaos

The Guardian reports that detailed mapping has pinpointed the carbon-rich forests and peatlands that humanity cannot afford ...

The Norweigan government has increasingly opened up the Barents Sea for oil drilling. Photo: © V. Belov / Shutterstock.com

Norwegian NGOs demand: "No new oil licences"

Norway is the fourteenth-largest global producer of oil and the second-largest of gas.

2015 to 2021 will be the seven warmest years on record. Photo: © SviatlanaLaza / Shutterstock.com

State of the climate in 2021

The World Meteorological Organization’s new analysis reports that in 2020, greenhouse gas concentrations ...

Just a few clicks and all the pollution is exported elsewhere. Photo: © Andrey_Popov / Shutterstock.com

Consumption in G20 kills 2 million people

We know that outdoor air pollution kills over 4 million people per year, but few have studied what causes these premature deaths.

Average emissions from new passenger cars have increased every year since 2017. The reason is spelled SUV. Photo: © vectorlab2D/ Shutterstockk.com

SUVs hinder emission reductions from traffic

The European Parliament’s Committee on the Environment (ENVI) recently published an Opinion on the Commission’s Sustainable and Smart Mobility Strategy.

Photo: © Neural Networks / Shutterstock.com

Even lower levels of air pollutants are mortal

A new report that examines the associations between low levels of air pollution and natural-cause, cardiovascular, respiratory ...

Only a few countries plan eco-shemes to support agroforestry. Photo: © Le Panda / Shutterstock.com

Eco-schemes must be sharpened to deliver

Eco-schemes is a new support mechanism in the CAP that was sealed in November. In a recent report ...

Coal-fired power plants in the Western Balkans cause around 19,000 premature deaths. Photo: © Dragan Mujan / Shutterstock.com

Western Balkans deserve cleaner air

A report from CEE Bankwatch Network and the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air ...

Breathe London

Citizens in London are provided with low-cost, easy-to-install sensors, so they can monitor air pollution in their local area.

Was it the Scottish water temperature that contributed to the lack of targets for ocean acidification? A new opportunity is given in Egypt next year. Photo: © gresei / Shutterstock.com

COP26 neglects ocean acidification

“COP26’s ocean acidification failure: States must protect the world’s oceans” is the title of a noteworthy text ...

'We are sinking': Tuvalu minister gives Cop26 speech standing knee deep in seawater

Foreign minister of Tuvalu gets his feet wet for COP26

A few years ago, The Guardian published an article on climate change effects on Tuvalu, which is a small Polynesian country.

In brief

The science of temperature overshoots

On behalf of CAN and AirClim, Climate Analytics has analysed the Impacts, Uncertainties and Implications for Near-Term Emissions Reductions if the planet overshoots a 1.5°C global temperature increase.

Climate science uses emission pathways to assess different trajectories towards limiting warming to specific warming levels, most commonly to below 1.5°C or 2°C. In recent years, so-called overshoot pathways have also increased in prominence. In overshoot pathways global mean temperatures temporarily exceed a specific target, such as 1.5°C, before bringing temperatures back down below the target.

https://climatenetwork.org/resource/the-science-of-temperature-overshoot...

 

Express your view on EU Air Quality

Have your say on the revision of the EU Ambient Air Quality Directives (2008/50/EC and 2004/107/EC). The European Green Deal announced this initiative under the umbrella of the Zero Pollution ambition for a toxic-free environment. Citizens and stakeholders are welcome to express their views. Public consultation is open until 16 December 2021.

Source: Air quality – revision of EU rules by European Commission, accessed October 2021 https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiative...

Vulnerable countries: high emitters must act

Some of the countries most vulnerable to climate breakdown have called on the UN and climate progressive countries to help them ensure high emitters upgrade their carbon targets, as called for at the COP26 in Glasgow. Countries such as Australia, which has refused to embrace strong carbon-cutting targets, would lose out economically. It would be “an uphill battle” to ensure adequate revisions to national carbon targets, and all those who want to see climate action must use the coming year to put pressure on the governments that had inadequate plans. At COP26, countries came forward with emissions-cutting targets, known as nationally determined contributions (NDCs), that would lead to an estimated 2.4°C of heating, far in excess of the 1.5°C set out in the Paris agreement. All countries agreed to return next year to COP27 in Egypt with reviewed targets. However, some countries are reluctant to strengthen their targets – Australia has already signalled its refusal, while the US and the EU have said their targets are good enough.

Source; Climate-vulnerable countries call for help forcing high emitters to act, The Guardian 18 November 2021

Climate Change threatens the capacity of oceans to store CO2

Rising temperatures could lead to substantial releases of carbon dioxide currently bound to the deep ocean floor, reports the BBC. This is extremely bad news, as the oceans have so far buffered some of the temperature rise that would otherwise have occurred because of the greenhouse effect of carbon dioxide. In fact, oceans take up about one third of the carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere. Part of the carbon is taken up by marine life and is eventually buried in the sea floor. According to the BBC, the amount of carbon stored in this way is counted in billions of tonnes. If carbon dioxide starts to be released from the sea floor, this would lead to additionally increased warming. Evidence for the release of carbon dioxide comes from experimental work within the iAtlantic research programme. The work specifically focused on the deep ocean, which covers more than 60 per cent of our globe. For the experiments, sediment (in essence, material that constitutes the sea floor) was brought from the abyss to the laboratory, and studied under temperatures that are predicted for the end of this century. Reportedly, temperature rise increases the release of carbon dioxide from these deep-sea sediments.

Source: Gills, V. “Ocean’s climate change ‘buffer’ role under threat”, https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-59214866