Nitrogen overload still harms ecosystems

Two-thirds of EU ecosystems are currently exposed to more nitrogen deposition than they can cope with and one-tenth is receiving too much acid fallout. Significant additional reductions in the emissions of ammonia, nitrogen oxides and sulphur dioxide are needed to correct the situation.

Critical loads are scientific estimates of the amounts of pollutants that various ecosystems can tolerate without being harmed. They are sometimes referred to as the limits on what “nature can tolerate.” If pollutant depositions exceed the critical load limit, damage to sensitive ecosystems will by definition occur sooner or later.

The maps show the extent to which European ecosystems are exposed to more air pollutant depositions than they can tolerate in the long term without damage, i.e. where the critical load limits for acidification and eutrophication (nutrient nitrogen) are exceeded, and how the situation has changed over time.

It should be noted that the maps give a snapshot of deposition versus ability to resist at a given point in time – they do not really reflect the environmental situation right now. Environmental monitoring, experiments and calculations show that there may be considerable time lags, and that the damage that has already been caused by excess air pollutant inputs will persist for decades, in some places even for centuries.

Following the emission cuts over the last 40 years in the main acidifying air pollutants, especially sulphur dioxide, the area of sensitive ecosystems at risk of acidification in Europe is now less than 250,000 square kilometres (km2), nearly eight times smaller than it was in 1980 (see table).

Table: Change in area of ecosystems exposed to excess deposition of eutrophying and acidifying air pollutants from 1990 to 2010 and projection for 2020 assuming full implementation of the revised Gothenburg Protocol (million km2).

Progress is however markedly slower for eutrophication, which is caused by excess nitrogen deposition. Here the affected area has shrunk by less than 40 per cent over the same time period, and still covers 1.6 million km2.

Assuming that all the European countries that agreed in May last year to adopt the revised Gothenburg Protocol under the Convention on Long-range Transboundary Air Pollution (see AN 2/12) actually implement their new emission reduction commitments by 2020, some further improvements are to be expected. But there is still a long way to go to actually achieve the long-term environmental objectives of the Protocol, one of which is that there should be no exceedance of the critical loads for acidification and eutrophication.

If all countries were to implement readily available technical emission abatement measures by 2020, the area at risk of acidification would shrink to only one per cent in Europe (three per cent in the EU) and that at risk of eutrophication to 22 per cent in Europe (38 per cent in the EU).

These figures on the expected environmental effects of the revised Gothenburg Protocol come from a recent scientific assessment by the Convention’s Coordination Centre for Effects (CCE). The figures and maps presented here are based on the 2008 critical loads database and a geographical mapping resolution of 50 x 50 kilometre squares.

More recently, deposition and critical loads data with a higher resolution (28 x 28 km) has also been developed, and some preliminary results of using this newest data are also included in the CCE analysis. These show that areas at risk remain largely the same when using the new set of data, and while the total area where acidity critical loads are exceeded turns out to be somewhat smaller, the area exposed to nitrogen overload is calculated to be even greater.

A tentative assessment of changes to ecosystem biodiversity in a number of classified nature areas (such as certain grasslands, scrublands and woodlands) in the EU indicates that in 1990 the area at risk – which is defined as the area where air pollutant deposition triggers more than a five-per-cent change in species diversity – covered around 290,000 km2. Full implementation of the Gothenburg Protocol commitments could reduce this area to 68,000 km2 by 2020.

Christer Ågren

Source: Modelling and mapping of atmospherically induced ecosystem impacts in Europe: CCE Status Report 2012. By M. Posch, J. Slootweg, J-P Hettelingh (eds). RIVM Report 680359004, Coordination Centre for Effects, Bilthoven, the Netherlands. www.rivm.nl/cce

Figure: Areas where critical loads for acidification are exceeded by acid depositions (left) and areas where critical loads for eutrophication are exceeded by nutrient nitrogen depositions (right) caused by emissions between 1980 (top) and 2020 (bottom), the last projected under the Revised Gothenburg Protocol (RGP).

 

 

How much do we need to cut emissions?

When evaluating the environmental improvements that are expected to result from the revised Gothenburg Protocol by 2020, scientists at the CCE also made a rough estimate of what additional reductions in acidifying and eutrophying emissions are needed to achieve levels of depositions that no longer exceed the critical load limits.

This was done using the very simplified approach of assuming uniform (same percentage) gradual emission reductions for all European countries and for international shipping. The starting point was the emission levels projected for 2020, assuming full implementation of the revised Gothenburg Protocol.

For eutrophication it was shown that an additional 70 per cent reduction in total nitrogen emissions (nitrogen oxides and ammonia) would bring the exceedance of the critical loads for nutrient nitrogen close to zero. The total area at risk of eutrophication in Europe would still cover about two per cent, but the magnitude of exceedance in these areas would be quite low.

As regards acidification, exceedance of the critical loads approached zero at an additional 60 per cent combined reduction in emissions of sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides and ammonia. The remaining area at risk in Europe would come down to less than one per cent.
No detailed analysis was made regarding the locations of the remaining areas at risk (e.g. their spread between countries) or what types of ecosystems (e.g. nature protection areas) would still be exposed to excess deposition.

 

Small chimneys – big emissions

The Danish Government and the European Commission have separately presented proposals for emission standards for new boilers and stoves. But to achieve noticeable near-term air pollution reductions it is essential to combine such standards with measures for existing installations.

Editorial: Unacceptable to wait another forty years

It is now 2013, the year declared by environment commissioner Potočnik as the year of air, and in a speech at the EEB air quality conference on 8 January, he said that poor air quality was the cause of 420,000 premature deaths in the EU in 2010 ..

EU citizens: we want stronger air quality policy

Almost four out of five Europeans believe that the EU should propose additional measures to address air pollution.

Running out of time – the LCPD bites at last

EU SO2 emissions have been cut by 80 per cent and NOx emissions halved between 1990 and 2010. Things are going to get even better, thanks to the Large Combustion Plant Directive (LCPD), introduced in 1988.

Progress too slow

Emission levels of carbon dioxide from the transport sector have levelled off, after the sharp reductions that followed the economic crisis in 2008. However there is still a notable absence of structural changes, such as modal shifts.

Revising EU air pollution policy

Significant additional emission reductions and accompanying environmental improvements can be achieved in the EU over the next 10-15 years. Health benefits alone far outweigh the extra costs for emission control.

WHO experts call for stronger EU air pollution policies

Long-term exposure to fine particulate matter (PM2.5) can trigger atherosclerosis, adverse birth outcomes and childhood respiratory diseases, according to a World Health Organization (WHO) review released on 31 January.

Nitrogen overload still harms ecosystems

Two-thirds of EU ecosystems are currently exposed to more nitrogen deposition than they can cope with and one-tenth is receiving too much acid fallout. Significant additional reductions in the emissions of ammonia, nitrogen oxides and sulphur dioxide ...

Scope for reducing ammonia emissions

By applying already known techniques and agricultural practices, the EU could reduce agricultural emissions of ammonia by more than 30 per cent, figures show in a new report from the International Institute for Applied System Analysis (IIASA).

Global mercury deal

On 19 January, after four years of deliberation, more than 140 countries agreed on the first global treaty to cut mercury pollution. It contains a mixture of mandatory and voluntary elements intended to control the growing global mercury crisis.
 

Emissions reallocated to end-users

Industries and homes together account for more than half of the energy-related greenhouse gas emissions, when emissions are aggregated at end-user level.

Road charges for lorries could cut air pollution

Introducing road charges for heavy goods vehicles that reflect the varied health effects of traffic pollution in different European countries would mean charges should be much higher in some countries compared to others.

Tailwind for wind

Wind power is coming of age. It supplies one-fortieth of the world’s electricity, and has grown tenfold in 10 years. There is room for much more. China and the US now lead the world.

No extension for the 2015 sulphur deadline

The European Commission on 25 January told France it will not authorise any EU country to seek an extension of the deadline for the 2015 sulphur limit of 0.10 per cent for marine fuels used in the European Sulphur Emission Control Areas ..

New US clean air standards for PM2.5

The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in December finalised an update to its national air quality standards for harmful fine particle pollution (PM2.5), setting the annual health standard ..

EU launches alternative fuels strategy

On 24 January the European Commission announced a package of measures to ensure the build-up of alternative fuel stations for transport across the EU with common standards for their design and use.

Stricter standards for motorcycles

On 11 December, the Council adopted a regulation laying down new safety and environmental requirements for motorcycles and other L-category motor vehicles (mopeds, quads and small vehicles with three or four wheels).

New legal approach to improve EU air quality

Ambient air quality is poor in many EU countries – despite an obligation for governments to ensure good air quality for citizens. Excessive levels of particulate matter (PM10) have led the Commission to take action against ..

Heavy metals treaty updated

In December, countries in Europe and North America ended three years of negotiations by agreeing updated emission control requirements for particulate matter and the three heavy metals cadmium, lead and mercury ..

High costs of mercury damage

Cleaning up mercury pollution and reducing prenatal exposure to methylmercury could save the European Union at least €9 billion per year, according to a new study published in the Environmental Health journal.

France and Germany want more time to meet NO2 limits

The European Commission has dismissed all applications from France to delay a 2010 deadline for meeting the EU’s NO2 air quality standard. It has also rejected many requests from Germany for derogations.

20 per cent for climate in EU budget

On 8 February, the EU heads of state agreed on a new budget for 2014–2020, which includes cuts by €32 billion compared with the previous budget period. Several budget items that are of major importance for green investments ..

WWF: 40 per cent renewables by 2030 is feasible

More than 40 per cent energy generated by renewables and 38 per cent less energy use compared to business as usual by 2030, leading to a reduction in greenhouse gases by 50 per cent compared to 1990 – these are the main ..

Savings will slash prices

Energy efficiency measures can lead to significantly lower energy prices, according to a recent study commissioned by Climate Action Network and Friends of the Earth Europe. Every €1 saved on not using energy ..

New publication:

Environmental Policy in the EU – Actors, Institutions and Processes. Non-students can also benefit from an educational overview of EU environment policy. The book, which is the third revised edition, contains short summaries ..